Billboard Lawyers
Over the last year, billboards from the law firm Miller, Dawson, Sigal & Ward Injury Attorneys have begun appearing around South Carolina. You may know them as “The Thumbs Up Guys.”
Billboards for trial lawyers pepper our interstates with messages. Most are benign. Morgan and Morgan says they are #1. Shelly Leeke promises No BS. HawkLaw touts “case maximizing.” George Sink is celebrating his 50th Anniversary.
But in at least two ways, the Thumbs Up Guys are different.
First, as shown by this photo taken by a motorist stuck at a railroad crossing, Thumbs Up urges the potential client to “give insurance the finger.” No doubt, this is an attempt to play on the fact that they are the Thumbs, but “the finger“?

According to Wikipedia, “Giving someone the (middle) finger, also known as flipping the bird or flipping someone off, is an obscene hand gesture. The gesture communicates moderate to extreme contempt, and is roughly equivalent in meaning to “f**k you”, “f**k off”, “go f**k yourself”, “shove it up your ass/arse” or “up yours.”
Is there any other meaning? No.
So, how is the message of such a billboard in compliance with the standards and codes of ethics of the South Carolina Bar Association and the state agency that monitors the Palmetto State legal profession, the South Carolina Supreme Court?
Thumbs Up is running another campaign in tandem with Give Insurance the Finger. This one touts their affiliation with the Clemson Athletics Department.
In one version, one of the attorneys is pictured with The Tiger mascot. In another, the firm turns a Dabo-ism into “Bring Your Own Guys” (rather than Guts, as the Clemson coach famously said) with Clemson logos.

Every day, in our state courts, plaintiff law firms use our terrible Joint & Several Liability statute to go after deep-pocketed tortfeasors. Defense law firms, on the other hand, defend the various companies that are being targeted.
The battle is fierce, and each side has a right to practice.
Tort Reform is a political issue as well, having dominated weeks of Senate deliberation in the 2025 legislative session as the two sides battled it out.
The bottom line is this: Clemson Athletics (which is not to blame here) is being portrayed as having a relationship with a firm that promises to tell legitimate South Carolina businesses to “f-off.”
Is that OK?

