State Policy Network filed an amicus brief with more than 30 organizations (including Palmetto Promise Institute) in support of The Buckeye Institute v. Internal Revenue Service—a case challenging a decades-old federal law that forces nonprofits to hand over the names and addresses of their largest donors to the IRS each year.
The brief argues that nonprofits have a First Amendment right to keep their donors private. Forced disclosure discourages people from supporting causes they believe in and can expose them to harassment.
It explains that even when the government ties disclosure to a benefit like tax-exempt status, the rule must still meet “exacting scrutiny”—a standard the IRS’s donor-disclosure requirement does not satisfy because it is neither narrowly tailored nor supported by a sufficiently important interest.
Christopher Dauer, President and CEO of State Policy Network, noted:
“The freedom to associate lies at the foundation of a free society—and is at the core of America’s constitutional system. The IRS’ demand for The Buckeye Institute’s donor lists is an assault on philanthropic freedom and the First Amendment. The IRS’ tactics carry echoes of Jim Crow-era forced donor disclosure tactics that the NAACP fought against over six decades ago. It was wrong then and it’s wrong today.
Nonprofit organizations—and the millions of generous Americans who support them—are vital to a healthy civil society, and protecting their ability to privately associate is essential to preserving that role. As this brief demonstrates, the IRS’ disclosure requirements are unconstitutional and would undermine the ability of Americans to support the organizations and issues they care about.”
Read the amicus brief here.
Learn more about The Buckeye Institute’s case, The Buckeye Institute vs. Internal Revenue Service, here.
You Can’t Defend What You Don’t Know: The School Choice Knowledge Gap
In this Op-Ed originally published in The Daily Signal, Education Director Ryan Dellinger addresses the often overlooked obstacle facing the school choice movement: a lack of public awareness. As we recover from the whirlwind that was the midterm election, one question is resonating through the education space—what happens to school choice? In several states, school choice
The lesson from this election? Be bolder
I’ve been thinking about what last week’s state House election results mean for South Carolina and the work ahead. I do not believe these losses should be read as a rejection of free market principles. Rather, I believe we have not moved far enough, fast enough to deliver the changes people need, nor done enough
PPI’s Dr. Oran Smith Named to Institute for Effective Governance
The American Council of Trustees & Alumni announced in October that Dr. Oran Smith, Senior Fellow at Palmetto Promise Institute, has been selected to serve on its Institute for Effective Governance® Advisory Council. Dr. Smith is being recognized for his decades of commitment to improving higher education. Currently, Dr. Smith serves as the Vice-Chair of
Promoting Public Policy that Helps South Carolinians Flourish
Stay informed on the important issues facing South Carolina today!
